- There’s been countless coming-of-age films made over
the years, but very few about black teenage girls growing up in France. As
director of Girlhood Celine Sciamma
says herself, black women are virtually ‘invisible’ in French cinema, while
portrayals of them in the media are often negative.
Admirably, Sciamma tells her film from the perspective
of a young black girl (Karidja Toure in her first feature film, whose excellent
and natural performance carries the film) as she leaves school and joins an
all-girl gang. By dramatizing her life in such an empathetic and non-judgmental
manner, Sciamma humanises the kind of person who might be frowned upon or
mistrusted if passed in the street.
Her life story is also moving and relatable, and does
not suffer from being made exotic as some films about ‘others’ in society are
guilty of. The politics of being an outsider are inevitably tangled up in the
story and are handled very deftly by Sciamma, and makes for a fascinating
counterpoint to Richard Linklater’s similar but white male-orientated Boyhood.
- French house music in the 1990s was undoubtedly an
exciting scene to be involved with, but the excitement never quite translates
to the screen in Eden. The
soundtrack is great, but we never get a sense for the craft and creativity that
goes into making the music, nor the thrill of experiencing it in a club.
The characters are all quite dull and difficult to engage
with, especially the protagonist (Felix de Givry), whose rise and fall shapes
the structure of the film. The usual staples of heavy drug taking, world tours
and romantic entanglements are present, but all unfortunately fall a little
flat.
That plot involves Viggo Mortensen playing a Danish
engineer in Argentina taking part in the Conquest of the Desert, who sets out to
find his daughter when she disappears. His search is more L’avventura than it is The
Searchers, as dialogue gradually decreases and he is absorbed more and more
into the landscape, before the film enters yet stranger territory in the final
third.
Alonso shot on location in the extraordinary looking
rural South America and manipulates lighting to give everything a stark, dreamy
colouring, while the narrow 4:3 aspect ratio gives a great sense of depth to
the vast landscape yet disarmingly offers little peripheral vision. It’s beautiful
to behold, but any meaning or message is oblique.
SP
No comments:
Post a Comment